Labcorp OnDemand is permanently lowering the regular price on select allergy tests. This is not a promotion — but with roughly 60% of traffic arriving new, a lower number alone communicates nothing. This is a landscape audit of how other retailers solve that problem, what separates a “permanent value” read from a “sale” read, and a recommended treatment for OnDemand.
Four findings that shape everything below.
IKEA’s “New lower price” is the cleanest permanent-value treatment in retail. Small typographic tag beside the price, the words “Previous price” rather than “Was,” no percentage, no savings math, no countdown, and a one-line reason-why. Their own FAQ says it outright: “this is not a sale! This is the new normal: a lower everyday price.”
Walmart’s Rollback looks like the obvious reference but is the wrong one — it is structurally a temporary markdown that reverts, and its red badge + Was/Now + strikethrough construction is exactly the salesy read we’re designing away from.
This is the one that changes the plan. Under the FTC’s Guides Against Deceptive Pricing, the rules attach to showing a former price next to a current price — expressly “whether accompanied or not by descriptive terminology.” California’s regulation defining “former price” already names “reduced from ___” and “was ___ now ___”, and says the list is non-exhaustive.
So dropping the words “sale,” “save,” and “% off” makes the treatment look less promotional and reduces how many rules are implicated — but it does not move us outside the former-price regime.
Jane’s question was whether a non-sale message can stay up past the ~30 days we self-impose on promos. The research points somewhere different than expected. California requires the former price to have prevailed within three months — or for the ad to clearly state the date that price was in effect. The FTC guides, Connecticut, and Massachusetts all contain the same “or disclose the date” alternative.
That gives us a concrete, sourced option if we ever need the runway: rather than an open-ended “Previous price $299,” run “$299 until July 2026” — the express statutory alternative in multiple states, with no obvious 90-day expiry.
Where we landed: we’re not using the dated version. Because this is a permanent price change, a date reads as a deadline on the new price — implying it’s temporary, which is the opposite of the message. And we don’t need the extra runway: the comparison callout only runs for the launch window (~a month, while the campaigns are live), which sits comfortably inside the three-month lookback. So the plain “Previous price $299” treatment carries the launch, and once the reduction stops being news we drop the comparison entirely rather than dating it.
Reference-pricing class actions roughly doubled over the last two years, and motions to dismiss are mostly failing. The pattern worth flagging: the biggest cases cluster on house-brand / private-label goods — J.C. Penney, Eloquii, Quince — because when the brand sets both prices, “the former price was never real” is easy to allege. OnDemand sells its own first-party tests, which puts us in that category.
The practical defense is documentation: dated records of what each SKU was priced at, for how long, and what actually sold at that price. Worth confirming we can produce that per allergy SKU before the treatment goes live.
How each retailer actually renders it. Specimens below are recreations built to match the described treatment — they illustrate structure, hierarchy, and copy, not exact brand assets.
/cat/lower-price/ browse destination, which communicates program rather than campaign purely through information architecture.Across every example, the same handful of cues decide whether a shopper reads “this is the new normal” or “better hurry.”
Two of these cues pull against each other. “No time element” is what makes a treatment read as permanent — but date disclosure is what gives a former-price comparison the longest legally-supported runway. For a permanent price change we resolve it in favor of permanence: no date. The comparison only runs for the launch window, which stays inside the three-month lookback without needing one — so the price never looks like it’s about to expire.
Jane is taking this to compliance and legal. This section is background for that conversation — it raises questions to ask, and is not a legal opinion or a recommendation on legal risk.
The core FTC provision is 16 CFR §233.1, the Guides Against Deceptive Pricing. A former price is a legitimate basis for comparison if it is “the actual, bona fide price at which the article was offered to the public on a regular basis for a reasonably substantial period of time.” The Guides are not formal regulations, but they function as the benchmark for enforcement and for private litigation.
The sentence that matters most for our question is §233.1(e), which applies the standard to a former price shown “whether accompanied or not by descriptive terminology such as ‘Regularly,’ ‘Usually,’ ‘Formerly,’ etc.” In other words the trigger is the comparison itself, not the vocabulary wrapped around it.
California is the strictest regime. Bus. & Prof. Code §17501 prohibits advertising a former price unless it was the prevailing market price “within three months next immediately preceding” the ad, “or unless the date when the alleged former price did prevail is clearly, exactly and conspicuously stated.” The companion regulation, 4 CCR §1301, defines “former price” to include — expressly “but not limited to” — “reduced from ___” and “was ___ now ___.”
| Source | What it says about duration |
|---|---|
| FTC 16 CFR §233.1 | No numeric limit. But a former price becomes problematic once it is no longer “recent” — unless the date is disclosed. |
| California §17501 | Former price must have prevailed within 3 months — or the ad states the date it prevailed. |
| People v. Overstock | Court-imposed injunction limited advertised reference prices to 90 days before revalidation. |
| Massachusetts 940 CMR 6.05 | Safe harbors at 14 days immediately preceding, or 28 of the preceding 90 days — extendable to any 90-day window in the prior 12 months if the date is disclosed. |
| Connecticut, New Jersey, Oregon, Missouri, Virginia, Georgia, DC | Variations on the same 28/90 or 90-day lookback pattern, several with their own disclosure alternatives. |
The recognized way to extend a former-price comparison past the lookback window is date disclosure — not permanence framing. That same “or disclose the date” escape valve appears in the FTC guides and in California, Connecticut, and Massachusetts law.
Worth setting expectations before the legal conversation: the research did not find a federal or California safe harbor for permanent-reduction framing. No FTC advisory opinion or enforcement action distinguishes it from a sale, and no case law holds that a truthful permanent-reduction announcement falls outside §17501 or §233.1.
The one provision anywhere that names the concept is Massachusetts 940 CMR 6.05(4)(d), which says it is not deceptive to decline to revert to a higher price where the item stays at the reduced price as a “permanent markdown” or “permanent price reduction.” But read closely, that excuses the revert obligation — it does not authorize running the comparison message indefinitely. Massachusetts is also the only state where this carve-out surfaced; California has no analogue.
One firm’s commentary maps directly onto our proposed framing and is worth quoting in the legal brief: a “new low price” claim is read for its net impression, and communicates “that there has been a reduction from the advertiser’s own prior price, that the prior price was bona fide, that the reduction is meaningful, and that the designation ‘new’ is temporally accurate.” That last clause is the duration question in different words — how long does “new” stay true?
The recommended treatments are built out and interactive in the prototype — open it to step through each one across PLP, PDP and cart.
Jacqueline asked whether this comes through programmatically like a sale, or gets built in Target. Both are viable; they trade speed against correctness.
| Path | How it works | Trade-offs |
|---|---|---|
| Fast “restyle the sale” |
Keep the existing sale mechanic — the discount flows through as it does today — and use Target to restyle it: kill the red, replace the “% off” line with the value label, swap “Was” for “Previous price” or the dated line. | + Fastest to launch; no catalog change; achievable in July. − The underlying record still says sale, which means it likely still carries a promo end date and may revert on its own. It also collides with the real promo calendar — if an allergy test enters a monthly promo, the two treatments fight. |
| Ideal “new regular price” |
Change the regular price in the catalog to the new number so there is no discount object at all. Target then overlays the value label and the previous-price line as presentation only. | + Structurally honest — the new price genuinely is the regular price, which is the whole premise. Frees the sale mechanic to keep doing promos independently. Cleanly supports dropping the comparison later once the reduction is no longer news. − Needs the catalog price change coordinated first; the previous price becomes a hard-coded string in Target that has to be maintained per SKU. |
These two paths differ in whether an allergy test can be in a monthly promo and carry the value-price treatment at the same time. Under the fast path it likely can’t. Worth deciding up front whether the reduced allergy tests are excluded from promos while the value message runs — that’s a merchandising decision, not a build one.
PDP and PLP are the shippable surfaces. Cart is out of scope for launch — guest checkout owns /checkout/cart and it’s one or the other. The prototype will include a cart treatment so we can see the end-to-end experience and pick it up once guest checkout concludes.
The Was/Now variant in the discount-framing test can’t be used for both a permanent price cut and a promotional discount — whichever one claims it, the other has to find a different treatment. Sequence is now: settle the value-price treatment first, then define the sale-price treatment against it. Sale urgency gets revisited in the same pass.